Finished
The
Worry Web Site (Dell Yearling, 2003). The book is comprised of linked
short stories about students in a British classroom and the various worries that
affect them—problems with parents and step-parents, self-esteem
issues, and first loves. The book is well-suited for fourth and fifth grade students
who face similar worries. Its portrayal of Natasha, a student with an unidentified
disability who uses a wheelchair and a
“special speaking machine,” alongside the worries of all the other
students nicely addresses the many similarities between Natasha’s worries
and those of the others in the class.
The Worry Web Site,
set up by teacher Mr. Speed, links the stories in the book, as each featured
student writes about a particular worry on the Web site. At most, the technology
sounds like an anonymous Web form that students can fill out. After a student
posts, other students in the class can respond. The site seems to be
something like an anonymous blog. Anyone can post, and anyone can reply. There
are classroom netiquette rules, but we don’t really learn anything
about the technology that the teacher has set up to make it all work . Technology
plays the role of connecting the stories, but readers have to guess about what
that technology actually is. There’s no indication, for instance, that
students can access the site outside of the classroom. Readers might guess then
that the Worry Web Site is a local site, available only on this one classroom
computer. There is not enough detail about the technology, however, for readers
to be sure.
Perhaps the undefined nature of the Worry Web Site is an attempt to keep the
book, originally published in Great Britain in 2002, from appearing dated. If
written today, the technology might be described as an anonymous blog, but there’s nothing else in the few details that
would cause a problem.
In fact, there’s nothing really special about the Worry
Web Site. The same sharing of worries and classroom feedback could easily be
achieved with a shared classroom journal. The only benefit of the Worry Web Site
over such a handwritten journal is the posture of anonymity—there is no
handwriting on the Web site to betray the author. Of
course, Mr. Speed knows who writes every message in spite of the anonymous
postings. There is no way to know if Mr. Speed is simply very clever or there
is a backdoor that lets him check the author’s name. It’s likely the
former, however, as even the students are able to guess who posts which worries:
One of the boys wrote that he liked one of the girls a lot. That made everyone
giggle—and Greg went very pink. Hmm! I wonder who he fancies?
Someone else went
on and on. Oh boo hoo, it’s so sad, I miss my dad, etc, etc. We all
know who that was. (p. 4)
Technology plays a role in the stories, then, but a subtle one. The messages
that the students write are always the focus, rather than the technology that
the students use to write those messages. Perhaps, then, the book shows that
technology has become more of a commonplace element of students’ lives.
It just is. There is a classroom computer, and students use it matter-of-factly
during their school day.
Jacqueline Wilson, the book’s author, is a two-time runner-up for the Carnegie
Medal, so I was expecting a bit more from the book. Terry Pratchett won the
Carnegie for The
Amazing Maurice and His Educated Rodents, and Wilson’s book
doesn't really compare to Pratchett’s—yes, I know that Pratchett
doesn't really compare to anyone :) In many ways, The Worry Web Site is predictable
and the stories rather simplistic. It is a good book, but not a great one.
I
would recommend it to students facing worries similar to those in the book,
but those readers with more complex anxieties would certainly need more support
than this book provides. There are suggestions of domestic violence and alcoholism,
for instance, but the student’s worries are treated rather superficially
and the bigger issues rae not dealt with. It is not a book to give to readers
looking for stories about technology. The computer and Web site do not play
a significant role, and students looking for something akin to video game action
will be disappointed.
********** (5
of 10 stars)
